Episodes

Subscribe and listen on a major platform
Latest Episode

The Pilgrims Revisited: What the First Thanksgiving Really Meant

Thanksgiving has become one of America’s most debated holidays — but what actually happened in 1621? In this episode of Signal Over Noise, historian David Bradford joins host Nathan Johnson to examine the original accounts of the Pilgrims, the Wampanoag, and the first Thanksgiving. Drawing from primary sources and historical context, Bradford challenges modern myths, explores the faith and motivations of the Pilgrims, and sheds light on the complex, often misunderstood relationship between Native tribes and the Plymouth Colony. A conversation about evidence, nuance, and why history deserves more than slogans.

All Episodes

The First Thanksgiving: Faith, Freedom, and the Story We Forgot

November 24, 2025

As Thanksgiving becomes a flashpoint in today’s culture wars, what parts of the original story are being forgotten? In this episode of Signal Over Noise, host Nathan Johnson speaks with Aaron Bradford, a direct descendant of Pilgrim governor William Bradford, about the people, faith, and sacrifices behind the first Thanksgiving. Drawing from firsthand accounts, family history, and primary sources, the conversation explores the Pilgrims’ quest for religious freedom, the Mayflower Compact, and the remarkable cooperation between the Plymouth settlers and the Wampanoag. A thoughtful look at why this moment in history still matters — and what it can tell us about gratitude, self-governance, and American identity.

Statues, Memory, & The Battle Over History

August 5, 2025

Jack and Claire explore the real consequences of tearing down statues, from Canada to the U.S. and the U.K. They cut through the rhetoric to discuss what’s really at stake when nations erase pieces of their past—and spotlight the fightback against historical amnesia.

Sussex’s Fine For Free Speech

July 9, 2025

A landmark £585,000 fine against the University of Sussex marks a turning point in defending academic freedom. Hosts Sarah and Jack unpack what happened to Professor Kathleen Stock, why this legal blow matters nationally, and what it signals for universities facing cancel culture. This episode dives into the case, the pushback, and how institutional accountability has become a reality in the culture war on campus.

Academic Freedom Under Fire

June 8, 2025

This episode examines the case of Frances Widdowson, a professor fired for challenging dominant campus orthodoxy. We explore how universities are navigating the tension between academic freedom and ideological conformity, and what it means for free inquiry in higher education today.

Community Fights Back Against Reckless Housing

May 5, 2025

We explore how residents are pushing back against poorly planned supportive housing, from Toronto’s Rosedale to cities across North America. With data, real stories, and the voices most affected, this episode shows why demanding safety and accountability isn’t selfish, but essential.

Sandmann Strikes Back

April 15, 2025

Nicholas Sandmann, a high school student thrust into a national media storm, fought back against false headlines and won settlements from America’s most powerful newsrooms. Jack and Claire break down the case, the court battles, and what Sandmann’s victory means for media accountability in the age of viral outrage.

When Campus Cancels: Free Speech and the Charter Gap

March 12, 2025

Sarah and Jack break down the UBC–Andy Ngo case, explore how ‘security’ justifications enable censorship, and spotlight the ongoing fight to ensure freedom of expression is defended at Canadian universities. Episodes of legal defeat reveal the deeper battlegrounds of culture and accountability—where every cancelled speaker raises new questions about rights on campus and the future of open inquiry.

Academic Freedom Act in Action

February 19, 2025

We break down the UK’s 2023 Academic Freedom Act, exploring what sparked this sweeping legal defence of campus speech, how the law reshapes university life, and why its impact matters far beyond the UK. Mike and Claire track real cases and bring their classic contrast, Midwest pragmatism meets punchy legal insight, to expose the big implications for free expression and cultural pushback.

Permits and Precedent — The Feucht Tour Cancellations

January 23, 2025

Jack and Claire delve into the free speech storm surrounding Sean Feucht’s cancelled Canadian tour. Was it safety, censorship, or something deeper? They unpack what this means for rights on both sides of the border.

Cancel Culture on the Run

December 12, 2024

Cancel culture’s grip on society is loosening, and a new era of free speech is taking shape. In this episode, we dissect the backlash against cancel culture, showcase real cases of resistance, and debate whether these changes signal a lasting shift or just a temporary pause.

The War Over Thanksgiving

November 22, 2024

This episode of Signal Over Noise digs into the myths versus the reality of Thanksgiving’s origins, examines the modern backlash against the holiday, and defends why the Pilgrim story—and the tradition of gratitude—still matter in America today. Jack and Claire cut through the noise of activism and narratives to find the enduring significance behind the nation’s most unifying holiday.

The Right to Say No

October 12, 2024

Sarah and Marcus break down the Supreme Court’s recent ruling on compelled speech, exploring its implications for personal liberty and free expression. Through real-world examples and historical perspective, they distinguish between discrimination and the right to dissent, revealing why the First Amendment protects even unpopular beliefs.

Students Push Back At UT

September 9, 2024

This episode dives into the University of Texas students’ legal battle against campus free speech restrictions, exposing the reality behind state promises. We break down the university’s restrictive policies, the student-led court challenge, and the broader implications for free expression on American campuses.